When it comes to television series, there’s nothing quite as painful for fans as an unexpected cancellation, especially when it leaves unanswered questions. This sentiment rings true for the dedicated fanbase of the “iCarly” revival, which recently received the heartbreaking news of its cancellation by Paramount+ after just three seasons.
The Return to the Iconic Apartment
The revival was not just a mere revisit; it showcased a grown-up version of the original Nickelodeon series that aired between 2007 to 2012. Fans rejoiced to see Miranda Cosgrove’s Carly and Nathan Kress’s Freddie back in the familiar setting of their iconic apartment. As the story evolved, Carly and Freddie’s relationship transformed from just friends in the original to a romantic twist in the revival, earning them the fan nickname “Creddie.”
Expressing his disappointment and gratitude, Nathan Kress shared on X (previously known as Twitter), “Obviously this stings a bit. We had a lot of story left to tell, and we were excited to give you guys the ending you deserved. No one wanted this to end on a cliffhanger.”
He continued to express his gratitude to the fans, cast, and crew, adding, “I’m so proud of what we accomplished together. Freddie is forever in my heart, and I’m honored that I was able to put that mantle back on, even for just a few more years.”
New Faces and Thankful Goodbyes
While the revival brought back original cast members Jerry Trainor, Miranda Cosgrove, and Nathan Kress, it also introduced fresh faces like Laci Mosley and the talented Jaidyn Triplett.
Triplett took to Instagram to share her feelings, appreciating the series and its veteran cast for their faith in her. Cosgrove responded warmly to Triplett’s post, stating, “You’re amazing Jaidyn. I truly can’t wait to see all the incredible things you do in your life. Thanks for being so hilarious and fun. Nobody could’ve brought your part to life like you ❤️.”
A Cliffhanger to Remember
The series left fans on tenterhooks with Carly and Freddie’s decision to get married, but just as things seemed to be heading to a joyous conclusion, drama ensued. Carly’s long-absent mother made a surprising entrance at the wedding venue. This unexpected twist left fans clamoring for more, wondering what might have been.
Nathan Kress hinted at the potential of revisiting the story in the future, noting, “Maybe somehow, someday, we’ll find out how [the] story ends.”
Fan Reactions
Thank you all for your kindness, love, and undying support for these past 3 seasons. I’m so grateful that we were given an opportunity to bring you this story… and I especially want to thank our amazing crew, writers, and my castmates for the greatest workplace and creative…
— Nathan Kress (@NathanKress) October 4, 2023
View this post on Instagram
This being the last scene and shot of icarly absolutely does not sit right with me “mom?” This cancellation HURTS especially towards my childhood 😩😭 #icarly pic.twitter.com/zGgHUGHrvx
— 𝙶𝚒𝚜𝚎𝚕𝚕𝚎✖️✖️// GEN V/Loki/OFMD ERA💥⏳🥀🐉 (@giselleb1234) October 4, 2023
This cannot be how iCarly ends… pic.twitter.com/TukRUqmG0q
— Hernandy (@hernandy_s) October 5, 2023
icarly was genuinely the best reboot we’ve ever gotten for a tv show and they go ahead and cancel it at its peak pic.twitter.com/oUsKeaClqw
— mara SAW BEY (@PARKERSFlLMS) October 4, 2023
icarly really got canceled after THAT cliffhanger. They really had us wait years for Carly and Spencer to finally mention their mom and we don’t even get to see her and we’ll never get that creddie marriage ITS SO OVER😭 #icarly
pic.twitter.com/ryeM66LJpn— 𝙶𝚒𝚜𝚎𝚕𝚕𝚎✖️✖️// GEN V/Loki/OFMD ERA💥⏳🥀🐉 (@giselleb1234) October 4, 2023
They wasted all that money making a boring ass Zoey 101 reboot that wasn’t needed but cancelling ICarly on the brink of a cliffhanger is where they draw the line!!!?? pic.twitter.com/SGxFSAVZsR
— ʞǝʌ ⓚ (@ThisIsKevWest) October 4, 2023
if y’all were ending icarly, paramount could’ve released a one hour special with carly’s mom being revealed and creddie’s wedding, just to tie loose ends.
— ً (@livviechens) October 4, 2023
the icarly reboot is quite literally the only good show with consistent viewers that paramount+ has… i’m not even joking, i checked the statistics. the thought of it being canceled means that service won’t be lasting another year pic.twitter.com/bKOy31LAER
— jolt (@meltborne) October 4, 2023
iCarly’s revival was the reason that a lot of people came to Paramount+ and that funny and incredible show will be a lovely piece of our hearts. Thanks, @NathanKress and @iCarly team for this years with us 🥺❤️#SaveICARLY #GoodbyeiCarly pic.twitter.com/sQmIC2J4lh
— Yadiel Barbón 🇨🇺 (@YadielBarbon) October 4, 2023
How long until showrunners realize it’s dumb to end a series on a cliffhanger? Nothing is guaranteed in the entertainment business. As networks & streamers start tightening their belts even more, it’s going to get worse.#iCarly pic.twitter.com/JrGshF4FRt
— Av (@MarioEmmet) October 4, 2023
iCarly deserves a final movie if this is going to officially be the end of the series https://t.co/Rk9Yd2t9qZ
— Laura | KC N1&2 🫶🏻 Never hugged Taylor🩵🩵🩵 (@LauraSwiftie24) October 4, 2023
ICarly really got cancelled with that cliffhanger ending it’s OVER for us pic.twitter.com/Em7iaXd6mI
— AJ | 🏳️🌈 | 🎃 Halloween Era 👻 (@AjepArts) October 4, 2023
Am I delusional? Like I could have sworn iCarly GREW in popularity over season 3???
— WhatTheClarke (@whattheclarke) October 5, 2023
the icarly reboot cancelled… the only good reboot to come out gone??? pic.twitter.com/a74hIdrMW7
— .k (@sqaureone) October 4, 2023
gotta say that what hurts the most about this is knowing that all the actors & crew really thought season 4 was a guarantee and they didn’t even get the chance to say their final goodbyes😭 @paramountplus #iCarly #SaveiCarly #WeWantiCarlyS4 pic.twitter.com/ikz44YGH19
— julie | #SaveiCarly (@StruckByStories) October 4, 2023
Even though the last episode aired on July 27, the series’ abrupt ending continues to resonate deeply within its community. Both Kress and Triplett’s posts have been flooded with fan comments, sharing their own reactions to the news and expressing hope for a potential continuation in some form.
In the ever-evolving world of television, while shows might come and go, the memories they create and the impact they leave on their viewers remain indelible. The iCarly revival, with its mix of nostalgia and fresh narratives, will undoubtedly be remembered fondly by its ardent fans.
