Are you yearning for the charm of Stranger Things? Is there a looming void in your heart that only Hawkins and the Upside Down used to fill? Worry no more because we’ve rustled up the perfect solution for you. We’ve gone above and beyond to unearth a collection of captivating supernatural series that, although lesser-known, are guaranteed to leave you on the edge of your seat.
With their enticing narratives and uncanny situations, these shows stand ready to mesmerize you right from their first chilling scenes.
Each series is an escape into a different realm, offering a unique blend of the supernatural and the extraordinary. We’ve delved into various genres to bring you the crème de la crème, with everything from mind-bending mini-series to intense dramas that skillfully infuse humor into their gripping narratives. Each show presents a new universe ripe for exploration, setting the stage for strange occurrences and otherworldly beings.
So, whether you’re yearning for an alternate universe, dealing with the restless dead, or just searching for some eccentric supernatural antics, you’ll find a show in this collection that resonates. Every twist and turn in these intricately woven narratives is designed to whet your appetite for the peculiar and the unexplainable.
1. The Lost Room (2006): Unleashing the Extraordinary in the Mundane
Let your imagination wander into a realm where normalcy takes a twist, where seemingly commonplace items possess incredible capabilities. Welcome to the fascinating universe of The Lost Room, a compelling series that injects the mundane with an irresistible dose of the extraordinary. Picture this: a nondescript motel key serving as the magic portal to an entirely different universe. Intriguing.
Though brief with just six episodes, this brilliantly crafted sci-fi mini-series is a rollercoaster of suspense, supernatural elements, and unanticipated turns. Its compelling plot and a dash of unpredictability keep you riveted right from the outset. The series may have had a fleeting run, but it left an indelible mark on its audience. Its enduring appeal is reflected in its impressive 77% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, a testament to its gripping narrative and stellar storytelling.
In The Lost Room, every element and event holds significance, no matter how minute. The allure of stepping into another dimension, of experiencing the unimaginable, becomes almost irresistible as you delve deeper into this series. Its charm lies in exploring the extraordinary hidden within the ordinary; all wrapped up in a mystery that leaves viewers hungry for more. So, get ready to embark on a compelling journey into the unknown, where the stakes are high and the laws of reality do not apply.
2. The Fades (2011): The Hauntingly Overlooked Supernatural Drama
Sometimes, the most captivating shows have a knack for sliding into the shadows, only to be uncovered by the most curious viewers. Such is the case with The Fades, a gripping British supernatural drama that, despite its inherent allure, has largely managed to elude the spotlight.
At the heart of this compelling series is Paul, a teenager grappling with more than just the typical adolescent woes. Haunted by terrifying visions of an impending apocalypse and endowed with an uncanny ability to perceive spirits known as the ‘Fades,’ Paul’s world is a labyrinth of the supernatural. His journey weaves a mesmerizing tale oscillating between reality and the eerie spectral world, keeping you utterly hooked.
However, even with a compelling narrative, exceptional performances, and a high approval rating that solidified its quality, The Fades, quite ironically, faded into the background after just a single season. It also proudly held the BAFTA award for Best Drama Series, a recognition that speaks volumes about its unmatched brilliance in an ocean of contemporary shows.
Yet, in its relative obscurity, The Fades has become a secret a niche audience shares. A deliciously spooky treasure is lying in wait, a gem of a series ready to trap the unsuspecting viewer with its chilling premise and captivating storytelling. It’s a voyage into the uncanny that promises to thrill and chill in equal measure, a must-watch for those eager to unearth a new, hidden obsession.
3. Utopia Falls (2020): A Dystopian Future Filled with Rhythm and Rebellion
Dive into the captivating world of Utopia Falls, where genres blend seamlessly, crafting a fresh and intriguing narrative. The series beautifully melds elements of a dystopian future with the vibrant beats of hip-hop, all while weaving in mysterious supernatural twists.
At its core, the tale follows a group of bright-eyed teenagers, each chosen for their exceptional talents to compete in a revered performing arts competition, a ticket to fame and respect in their society.
However, what begins as a quest for artistic glory takes a sudden, unexpected detour. While preparing for the competition, these youngsters stumble upon ancient cultural artifacts, relics from a past long forgotten or perhaps deliberately concealed. These discoveries challenge everything they’ve ever known, shaking the foundation of their beliefs and societal norms.
As they grapple with these revelations, a spark of rebellion ignites, slowly fanning into a revolution that threatens to change the landscape of their world.
Utopia Falls masterfully captures the spirit of youth, rebellion, and the timeless quest for truth. As viewers, we’re pulled into the whirlwind of their discovery, experiencing the rollercoaster of emotions, from awe to disbelief, alongside the protagonists. The series beckons those with a penchant for unconventional storytelling to embark on this riveting journey, where music meets mystery, and the past has the power to redefine the future.
4. The Returned (French: Les Revenants) (2012-2015): A Resurrection Drama Like No Other
The Returned is an enthralling French supernatural drama that delves into uncharted territories of the afterlife. The premise is enough to send shivers down your spine: imagine loved ones, believed to be gone forever, suddenly returning from the dead, seemingly untouched by time.
But the series isn’t just about the shock of their return. It digs deeper, examining the profound ripple effect of these unexpected resurrections on the tight-knit community. Families and friends must grapple with a whirlwind of emotions — from disbelief and joy to fear and uncertainty. How does a community reconcile with the past that’s suddenly thrust into the present?
The series stands out not just for its unique plot but also for its richly textured atmosphere. It’s a slow burn, drawing viewers into its moody, haunting ambiance with every scene. The subtitles shouldn’t deter you even if you’re not fluent in French. The raw emotions and intricate storyline transcend language barriers.
The Returned has managed to captivate audiences and critics alike. This is evident in its commendable 67% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, a testament to its cinematic brilliance. For those searching for a gripping drama with a supernatural twist, this series promises an unforgettable viewing experience, blending mystery, emotion, and a touch of the otherworldly.
5. Carnivàle (2003-2005): Journey into the Mysteries of a Dust Bowl Carnival
The mesmerizing realm of Carnivàle is where the mystique of a traveling carnival intertwines with the stark realities of the Great Depression era. This supernatural drama is no ordinary show; it’s a rich tapestry of tales, where each character holds a story waiting to unravel.
From fire-breathers to fortune tellers, Carnivàle introduces us to various complex personalities, each more intriguing than the last. These characters don’t just entertain; they draw you into their world of secrets and dreams. Layered with profound biblical symbolism, the series often leaves viewers pondering long after an episode ends, seeking meaning and connections in its intricate web.
The narrative itself is a masterclass in storytelling. It seamlessly fuses the struggles of that era with supernatural elements, creating a compelling and thought-provoking plot—every twist and turn beckons, urging you to delve deeper into the carnival’s mysterious world.
Even though Carnivàle saw an untimely end after just two seasons, its spellbinding journey remains etched in the memories of its viewers. Rather than diminishing its appeal, its abrupt conclusion has only added to its allure, making it a cult classic. Suppose you’re searching for a series that challenges your perceptions and offers more than surface-level entertainment. In that case, Carnivàle stands tall as a must-watch in supernatural dramas.
6. Dead Like Me (2003-2004): Grim Reaping with a Humorous Twist
Journey into the quirky universe of Dead Like Me, a show that dares to take a lighthearted look at a topic as profound as death. It’s a tale of grim reapers, but not the ones you might expect. Instead of the traditional cloaked figures wielding scythes, the reapers here come with their quirks, colorful personalities, and relatable challenges.
The show expertly infuses dark humor into its narrative, making you chuckle even in the face of mortality. Every episode introduces you to a cast of engaging characters, each navigating the supernatural realm uniquely. Their adventures, mishaps, and day-to-day struggles offer a refreshing take on an age-old subject.
And it seems viewers and critics alike couldn’t get enough. Boasting an impressive 84% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, Dead Like Me stands out as an innovative gem in the vast world of television. This isn’t just any show; it’s a witty and heartwarming spin on life, death, and everything in between.
The brilliance of Dead Like Me can be attributed to the creative vision of Bryan Fuller.
His unique touch is evident throughout the series, setting it apart from the typical supernatural fare. And this was just the beginning for Fuller. He later spearheaded other acclaimed series, including the chilling Hannibal and the mythological extravaganza American Gods. Through Dead Like Me, we get an early glimpse of Fuller’s ingenuity and flair for the entertainment world.
If you’re in the mood for something different, something that challenges conventions yet warms the heart, this series is your perfect pick.
7. Misfits (2009-2013): Superpowers, Community Service, and British Humor
Step into the quirky universe of Misfits, a show that redefines the superhero genre in the most unexpected ways. It’s a tale about a motley crew of young offenders, each with their own set of challenges and personal demons. But a fateful encounter with a bizarre electrical storm turns their world upside down.
These ordinary teens are suddenly bestowed with superpowers, taking them from community service to a whirlwind of supernatural adventures.
What sets Misfits apart is its unique storytelling approach. It isn’t just about heroes saving the day; it’s about young individuals navigating the challenges of adolescence, all while grappling with newfound abilities. Imagine dealing with regular teenage angst and then adding superpowers to the mix!
It’s an emotional rollercoaster, where one moment, you’re laughing at their misadventures, and the next, you’re immersed in the drama of their struggles.
This British gem effortlessly blends comedy and drama, creating a riveting narrative that keeps you hooked. Its eccentricity is its charm, offering a fresh perspective on the age-old tale of superhuman abilities.
With a healthy dose of British wit and a backdrop of supernatural elements, Misfits stands out as a one-of-a-kind series in the vast realm of television entertainment. If you’re looking for a show that breaks the mold, offering both laughs and heart, Misfits is an absolute must-watch.
8. Fortitude (2015-2018): A Chilling Mystery in the Arctic Circle
Fortitude is a show that brilliantly marries the eerie beauty of the Arctic with the suspense of a psychological thriller. Nestled in the vast expanses of the Arctic Circle, the town of Fortitude might seem like a peaceful retreat at first glance. Its pristine landscapes and breathtaking views can easily lull you into serenity. But looks can be deceiving.
Beneath the town’s tranquil facade lurks a chilling mystery. An unseen supernatural force is at play, turning the once-quiet settlement into a hotbed of unsettling events. The cold isn’t the only thing that’ll send shivers down your spine in Fortitude. The series masterfully intertwines the environment’s natural beauty with the eerie and unexpected, making every twist and turn all the more spine-tingling.
The show’s strength doesn’t just lie in its plot. The ensemble cast delivers powerful performances, drawing viewers deeper into the unfolding drama. Every episode blends suspense, emotion, and sheer atmospheric tension.
For those who love a good thriller where the setting plays as significant a role as the characters, Fortitude is an experience not to be missed. It’s more than just a TV show; it’s a journey into a world where beauty and horror coexist in the most unexpected ways.
9. Penny Dreadful (2014-2016): A Macabre Love Letter to Gothic Literature
Penny Dreadful is a series that masterfully weaves together some of the most iconic horror stories ever told. Drawing inspiration from timeless tales like Dracula, Frankenstein, and Dorian Gray, the show crafts its shadowy universe filled with suspense and intrigue.
Every episode feels like flipping through the pages of an old gothic novel. The settings are atmospheric, drenched in the eerie ambiance that makes the hair on the back of your neck stand up. Shadows play tricks, and every floorboard creak echoes with mystery, making you feel like you’re walking through a haunted mansion.
But what indeed elevates Penny Dreadful is its storytelling. The plot doesn’t just retell these classic stories; it reinvents them, offering fresh perspectives and unexpected twists that keep viewers on the edge of their seats.
Alongside this, the cast delivers standout performances, breathing life into beloved and original characters with depth and emotion.
Penny Dreadful is an unmissable treat for those who cherish a blend of literary classics and spine-chilling suspense. It’s a masterclass on how to refresh age-old tales for a new audience while retaining the essence that made them unforgettable in the first place. Whether you’re a seasoned horror enthusiast or looking for a riveting story, this series promises an enthralling ride through the darker corners of classic literature.
10. Being Human (UK) (2008-2013): Supernatural Roommates and the Struggles of Being Human
Dive into the world of “Being Human,” the original UK series that takes a fresh and intriguing approach to the supernatural realm. Set in the vibrant city of Bristol, the show revolves around three unlikely roommates: a vampire with a conscience, a werewolf struggling with his instincts, and a ghost coming to terms with her past.
Their peculiar domestic setup might sound like the beginning of a joke, but the stories that unfold are anything but.
With a stellar 100% score on Rotten Tomatoes, “Being Human” doesn’t just throw mythical creatures into modern-day scenarios. Instead, it delves deep, examining each character’s intricate emotions, challenges, and desires. The show touches upon the age-old question: What does it mean to be human? Viewers get a chance to reflect on love, friendship, guilt, redemption, and so much more through the lens of these supernatural beings.
And there you have it, folks! A list of ten spellbinding series brimming with its brand of supernatural charm and allure. From eerie French dramas to mind-bending tales of alternate universes, these shows pack a punch and are perfect for anyone seeking a dash of the extraordinary.
So, if the conclusion of “Stranger Things” has left a void, fret not! Dive into these series and let yourself be enchanted by their mesmerizing stories. Whether you’re in the mood for ghosts, werewolves, or tales from the future, there’s something on this list to whisk you away into the world of the mysterious and fantastic.
