From the original comics to animated shows, and yes, the illustrious film adaptations—Superman is an enduring icon who has impressed fans for decades. With the recent news that James Gunn is directing a new installment, titled Superman: Legacy, there’s a renewed buzz about where this caped crusader could take us next. Here’s a comprehensive look at the previous nine live-action Superman movies that have graced the big screen.
Changing of the Guard: Henry Cavill to David Corenswet
Before we dive into the list, it’s worth acknowledging the latest casting news. David Corenswet will be donning the iconic red cape in James Gunn’s Superman: Legacy, taking over from Henry Cavill, who has been the face of the Man of Steel for a generation.
“The arrival of a new cinematic Superman is always a big deal, as he is the most popular and iconic superhero of all time.”
Now, without further ado, let’s explore the Superman film landscape.
Superman IV: The Quest for Peace (1987)
This is a film even Christopher Reeve couldn’t save. Superman IV: The Quest for Peace is often cited in discussions about the worst movies ever made.
“The film suffers from a plot that fails to engage audiences, action scenes that fail to impress, poor special effects, and the inability to understand or capture the joy of the first two Superman films.”
Reeve’s last ride as Superman marked a 19-year hiatus for the franchise. Stream on Max
Superman III (1983)
Another entry from the Reeve era, Superman III didn’t fare much better than its successor.
“Superman III is better than Superman IV: The Quest for Peace, but that’s not saying much.”
The film’s campy tone, lack of a compelling villain, and inconsistency in its portrayal of Superman left audiences underwhelmed. Stream on Max
Batman v. Superman: Dawn of Justice (2016)
A polarizing entry for sure, Zack Snyder’s Batman v. Superman deconstructed two iconic characters to mixed reviews.
“Batman v. Superman is a film with incredible cinematography, an excellent score by Hans Zimmer and Junkie XL, but it also seems to be a movie that either does not get Superman or even likes him.”
It was a risky move for Warner Bros., one that had divisive consequences. Stream on Max
Justice League (2017)
The studio interference and troubled production were quite evident in Justice League.
“Justice League is a confused corporate product that serves only as Warner Bros.’ attempt to course-correct after the mixed reception to Batman v. Superman.”
Nevertheless, the film did manage to capture the classic sweetheart nature of Superman that fans adore. Stream on Max
Zack Snyder’s Justice League (2021)
The “Snyder Cut” offered a broader, richer look into Superman’s role within the DCEU.
“It is fantastic seeing Superman inspire and save the world with the Justice League.”
This four-hour epic presented a much-improved take on the Man of Steel. Stream on Max
Man of Steel (2013)
Zack Snyder’s Man of Steel aimed for a modern, realistic interpretation of Superman.
“The movie features incredible action scenes but also is a major problem with the movie as Superman does not seem to be concerned with saving people.”
Its bold creative choices left audiences both stunned and divided. Stream on Max
Superman II (1980)
This sequel built on the success of its predecessor, delivering an emotionally rich storyline.
“Superman II manages to take a larger-than-life character like Superman and humanize him.”
It was an iconic superhero film that set a benchmark for future sequels. Stream on Max
Superman Returns (2006)
After a long hiatus, Brandon Routh brought Superman back to the big screen in Superman Returns.
“A fantastic Lex Luthor, solid visual effects, a new story, and the talent of Brandon Routh allow Returns to be a strong Superman film.”
Though somewhat held back by nostalgia, the film has aged well. Stream on Max
Superman: The Movie (1978)
The original and some say still the best, Superman: The Movie is a timeless classic.
“The film is such a great source of inspiration that Marvel Studios president and producer Kevin Feige watches the film before working on any of his Marvel Studios projects.”
Christopher Reeve’s portrayal remains the golden standard for Superman on film. Stream on Max
Beyond the Screen
With the upcoming Superman: Legacy, it’s clear that the legacy of Superman movies is far from over. As each actor dons the cape, as each director yells cut, Superman will continue to evolve, taking us on journeys we can only dream of. Here’s to the future of the Man of Steel on the big screen!
