When it comes to Ryan Reynolds, most fans immediately think of his quick-witted, fourth-wall-breaking role in Deadpool. But before he donned the red spandex and became everyone’s favorite anti-hero, Reynolds was charming audiences in a string of romantic comedies during the 2000s. Among these films, Definitely, Maybe stands out as one of his most memorable performances, featuring a proposal scene so touching, even the mighty Thor himself might shed a tear.
Ryan Reynolds’ Journey Through Rom-Coms: A Pre-Deadpool Era
Before he was dishing out sarcastic quips as Wade Wilson, Ryan Reynolds was melting hearts in romantic comedies. From Just Friends to The Proposal, Reynolds proved his versatility by playing the charming, sometimes awkward, but always endearing romantic lead. In 2008’s Definitely, Maybe, he took on one of his most nuanced roles yet, sharing the screen with talents like Elizabeth Banks, Rachel Weisz, and Isla Fisher.
The film tells the story of Will Hayes (Reynolds) recounting his romantic history to his daughter, played by Abigail Breslin, as he unravels the mystery of which one of his past flames is her mother. This narrative structure allowed Reynolds to explore a wide range of emotions, from nostalgic humor to deep vulnerability, showcasing his talent beyond the comedic chops for which he’s now famous.
The Proposal Scene That Had Fans (And Thor) Reaching for Tissues
One of the film’s standout moments is undoubtedly the proposal scene between Ryan Reynolds and Isla Fisher. In this emotionally charged scene, Reynolds’ character pours out his heart, expressing his love in a way that’s both genuine and poignant. The raw emotion in this scene struck a chord with audiences, making it one of the most memorable moments in Reynolds’ filmography.
The impact of this scene was so profound that some fans have humorously speculated it as the reason why Thor, played by Chris Hemsworth, was seen crying in Deadpool & Wolverine. Given Thor’s romantic side, as seen in Thor: Love and Thunder, it’s easy to imagine the god of thunder being moved by such a sincere expression of love. One fan on Instagram, @rolstu.ssi, even commented:
The reason Thor was crying
linking the emotional moment in Definitely, Maybe to the scene in Deadpool.
Definitely, Maybe: A Rom-Com That Defied Expectations
What sets Definitely, Maybe apart from other romantic comedies of its time is its unconventional approach to the genre. Instead of following the typical rom-com formula, the film introduces an element of mystery, making it more of a romantic “who-done-it.” This unique twist is part of what attracted Ryan Reynolds to the project in the first place.
In an interview with Blackfilm.com, Reynolds spoke about what drew him to the film:
One of the things that attracted me to the part was that it felt like a romantic who-done-it. It felt really unusual, actually, for a romantic comedy. I wouldn’t even necessarily call it a romantic comedy because the comedy, albeit present in the film, felt sort of incidental. It just felt like a great story though. It was an unpredictable story. I had no idea who Will was going to end up with, or in what fashion. I also feel like the movie is a love letter to broken families.
This unpredictability, coupled with the film’s heartfelt narrative, has earned Definitely, Maybe a special place in the hearts of fans. Though not as commercially successful as some of Reynolds’ other films, it has garnered a loyal following over the years, with many praising its refreshing take on love and relationships.
The Legacy of Definitely, Maybe in Ryan Reynolds’ Career
While Definitely, Maybe might not be the first film that comes to mind when thinking of Ryan Reynolds, it remains a significant part of his career, particularly in showcasing his ability to balance humor with genuine emotion. The film currently holds a 71% rating on Rotten Tomatoes, with critics praising its fresh approach to the romantic comedy genre.
Despite being an overlooked gem in his filmography, Definitely, Maybe grossed $55 million worldwide against a $24 million budget. As more fans discover this hidden treasure, the movie continues to resonate, offering a feel-good narrative that’s as unpredictable as it is heartwarming.
For those who haven’t yet seen it, or for those looking to revisit a beloved classic, Definitely, Maybe offers a chance to see Ryan Reynolds in one of his most charming and sincere roles. And who knows? You might find yourself shedding a tear, just like Thor.
