The NFL playoffs have always been a breeding ground for unforgettable moments and astonishing upsets. Throughout the league’s storied history, there have been games where underdog teams defied the odds and emerged victorious against seemingly invincible opponents. These dramatic turnarounds are what make the NFL playoffs so exhilarating for fans and players alike. This article delves into the top 10 NFL playoff upsets in history, showcasing the grit, determination, and sheer unpredictability of the sport.
Football is a game of strategy, skill, and sometimes, sheer luck. The playoffs amplify these elements, as every team vies for a chance to lift the coveted Vince Lombardi Trophy. While the regular season offers a glimpse of a team’s capabilities, the playoffs are where legends are made. Underdogs, often written off by analysts and fans, have time and again proven that heart and perseverance can triumph over talent and statistics. These games highlight the beauty of the sport, where any team, on any given day, can change the course of history with an extraordinary performance.
From stunning last-minute comebacks to defensive masterclasses and clutch performances, the history of the NFL playoffs is rich with instances where the unlikely became reality. These upsets are not just games; they are stories of resilience, tactical brilliance, and moments of individual heroism that have inspired countless fans and players. They remind us why the NFL is one of the most unpredictable and thrilling sports leagues in the world. Let’s dive into these monumental upsets that have left an indelible mark on NFL history and continue to be celebrated as some of the greatest moments in sports.
1. The Miracle of the Meadowlands II: Philadelphia Eagles vs. New York Giants (2010)
The first game on our list is a modern classic that remains etched in the memory of NFL fans. On December 19, 2010, the Philadelphia Eagles faced the New York Giants in a crucial NFC East matchup. The Giants, leading 31-10 with just over eight minutes remaining, seemed destined for victory. However, what followed was one of the most remarkable comebacks in NFL history.
Led by quarterback Michael Vick, the Eagles orchestrated a series of quick touchdowns, cutting the deficit to 31-24. Vick’s performance in those final minutes was nothing short of spectacular. He threw precise passes and made critical runs that kept the Eagles’ hopes alive. With less than two minutes remaining, the Eagles scored again, tying the game at 31-31.
The climax came with just seconds left on the clock. Giants punter Matt Dodge was instructed to punt the ball out of bounds to prevent a return, but instead, he kicked it straight to DeSean Jackson. Jackson bobbled the ball initially but then returned the punt 65 yards for a game-winning touchdown as time expired, completing an incredible 38-31 comeback victory.
This game underscored the unpredictability of the NFL and the importance of playing until the final whistle. It also highlighted Vick’s redemption story, as he had returned to the NFL after serving time in prison for dog fighting, and his performance in this game was a testament to his resilience and talent.
2. Super Bowl XXXVI: New England Patriots vs. St. Louis Rams (2002)
The New England Patriots’ victory over the St. Louis Rams in Super Bowl XXXVI is often cited as one of the biggest upsets in NFL history. The Rams, known as “The Greatest Show on Turf,” boasted an explosive offense led by quarterback Kurt Warner and running back Marshall Faulk. They were heavily favored to win against the Patriots, who were led by a relatively unknown quarterback named Tom Brady and head coach Bill Belichick.
The game was a defensive battle, with both teams struggling to find the end zone. The Patriots’ defense, masterminded by Belichick, managed to stifle the high-flying Rams offense, limiting their scoring opportunities. On offense, Brady played with the poise of a seasoned veteran, making smart decisions and avoiding costly turnovers. With the game tied at 17-17 in the final moments, Tom Brady led a masterful drive to position the Patriots for a game-winning field goal.
Kicker Adam Vinatieri nailed a 48-yard field goal as time expired, sealing a 20-17 victory and marking the beginning of the Patriots’ dynasty. This upset showcased the emergence of Brady as a clutch performer and solidified Belichick’s reputation as a defensive genius. It also highlighted the importance of preparation and game planning, as the Patriots were able to neutralize the Rams’ potent offense with a well-executed defensive scheme.
3. Super Bowl XLII: New York Giants vs. New England Patriots (2008)
Another monumental upset involving the Patriots occurred in Super Bowl XLII, but this time, they were on the losing end. The New England Patriots entered the game with a perfect 16-0 regular-season record and were expected to complete a historic undefeated season by defeating the New York Giants. The Giants, led by quarterback Eli Manning, had other plans.
The game was a defensive slugfest, with both teams struggling to score. The Patriots held a slim 14-10 lead late in the fourth quarter, but the Giants mounted a last-minute drive. The defining moment came when Manning evaded a sack and completed a miraculous 32-yard pass to David Tyree, who pinned the ball against his helmet to make the catch.
This play, known as the “Helmet Catch,” kept the drive alive and set up Manning’s game-winning touchdown pass to Plaxico Burress. The Giants’ 17-14 victory ended the Patriots’ perfect season and remains one of the most shocking upsets in Super Bowl history.
The Giants’ defense, led by defensive coordinator Steve Spagnuolo, played a crucial role in this upset. They managed to pressure Tom Brady consistently, sacking him five times and forcing him to make hurried throws. The Giants’ front four, particularly Michael Strahan, Osi Umenyiora, and Justin Tuck dominated the Patriots’ offensive line, disrupting their rhythm and preventing them from establishing their high-powered offense.
Eli Manning’s performance under pressure was equally impressive, as he orchestrated the game-winning drive with calm and precision. This game highlighted the importance of defensive pressure and clutch performances in the playoffs, as the Giants’ defense and Manning’s heroics combined to create one of the most memorable upsets in NFL history.
4. Super Bowl III: New York Jets vs. Baltimore Colts (1969)
Super Bowl III is one of the most famous upsets in NFL history, largely due to the bold prediction made by Jets quarterback Joe Namath. The Baltimore Colts were heavily favored to win, with many experts considering them one of the best teams ever assembled. The Jets, representing the AFL, were seen as inferior to their NFL counterparts.
Namath, however, guaranteed a Jets victory, a statement that was met with skepticism and ridicule. On January 12, 1969, Namath and the Jets backed up his words with a stunning 16-7 victory over the Colts. Namath was named the game’s MVP, despite not throwing a touchdown pass, as he expertly managed the game and avoided turnovers. The Jets’ defense played a crucial role, stifling the Colts’ powerful offense.
This upset not only validated the AFL but also paved the way for the AFL-NFL merger, fundamentally changing the landscape of professional football.
The Jets’ game plan was executed to perfection. Their defense, led by linebackers Larry Grantham and Al Atkinson, applied constant pressure on Colts quarterback Earl Morrall, forcing him into three interceptions. The Jets’ secondary, anchored by cornerback Johnny Sample, effectively shut down the Colts’ passing game. On offense, Namath utilized a balanced attack, relying on the running game to control the clock and keep the Colts’ offense off the field.
Running back Matt Snell had a standout performance, rushing for 121 yards and a touchdown, while Namath made timely completions to move the chains. This game showcased the importance of a well-rounded team effort and solid game planning, as the Jets executed their strategy flawlessly to secure one of the greatest upsets in NFL history.
5. 1996 AFC Divisional Playoff: Jacksonville Jaguars vs. Denver Broncos
The Jacksonville Jaguars were a relatively new franchise, having been established just a few years earlier. In the 1996 season, they made an improbable run to the playoffs and faced the heavily favored Denver Broncos in the AFC Divisional Playoff. The Broncos, led by future Hall of Fame quarterback John Elway, were expected to steamroll the Jaguars en route to a Super Bowl appearance.
However, the Jaguars, led by quarterback Mark Brunell and head coach Tom Coughlin, had other plans. They executed a brilliant game plan, combining a strong running game with timely passing. Brunell’s performance, coupled with key plays from running back Natrone Means, propelled the Jaguars to a shocking 30-27 victory. This upset demonstrated that even fledgling franchises could compete with the league’s elite and that no playoff game should be taken for granted.
The Jaguars’ defense played a significant role in the upset. They managed to contain Elway and the Broncos’ potent offense, forcing two critical turnovers that shifted the momentum in their favor. Cornerback Aaron Beasley had a standout performance, intercepting Elway in the fourth quarter to help seal the victory. On offense, Brunell made several clutch throws, including a 31-yard touchdown pass to wide receiver Jimmy Smith, who had a breakout game with over 100 receiving yards.
Natrone Means provided balance with his powerful running, amassing 140 yards and a touchdown on the ground. This game highlighted the importance of a balanced attack and the ability to perform under pressure, as the Jaguars’ offense and defense combined to pull off one of the most surprising upsets in playoff history.
6. 1981 NFC Championship: San Francisco 49ers vs. Dallas Cowboys
The 1981 NFC Championship Game between the San Francisco 49ers and the Dallas Cowboys is famous for “The Catch,” a play that has become legendary in NFL lore. The Cowboys were perennial contenders and were favored to win against the up-and-coming 49ers, led by a young quarterback named Joe Montana.
The game was tightly contested, with both teams trading blows throughout. With less than a minute remaining and the 49ers trailing 27-21, Montana orchestrated a final drive. On a third-and-three from the Cowboys’ six-yard line, Montana rolled right and threw a high pass to the back of the end zone.
Dwight Clark leaped and made a fingertip catch, securing the touchdown and giving the 49ers a 28-27 lead. The 49ers’ defense held on, and the victory marked the beginning of a dynasty for San Francisco, as they went on to win four Super Bowls in the 1980s. This game signaled the arrival of Montana as one of the greatest quarterbacks in NFL history and demonstrated the 49ers’ resilience in clutch moments.
The 49ers’ defense, under the guidance of defensive coordinator George Seifert, played a crucial role in the upset. They managed to contain the Cowboys’ explosive offense, led by quarterback Danny White and running back Tony Dorsett. Cornerback Ronnie Lott, who was a rookie at the time, had a standout performance, making key tackles and deflecting passes.
On offense, Montana’s leadership and poise were evident throughout the game. He completed 22 of 35 passes for 286 yards and three touchdowns, demonstrating his ability to perform under pressure. The offensive line provided solid protection, allowing Montana the time he needed to make critical throws. This game highlighted the importance of resilience, preparation, and clutch performances, as the 49ers overcame the odds to secure a memorable victory.
7. 2007 NFC Divisional Playoff: New York Giants vs. Dallas Cowboys
The 2007 season saw the New York Giants embark on a remarkable playoff run, culminating in a shocking upset over the Dallas Cowboys in the NFC Divisional Playoff. The Cowboys, led by quarterback Tony Romo, had dominated the regular season and were the top seed in the NFC. The Giants, on the other hand, were a wild-card team that had barely made it into the playoffs.
Despite the odds, the Giants played a gritty and determined game. Eli Manning delivered a solid performance, while the Giants’ defense, led by defensive end Michael Strahan, stifled the Cowboys’ high-powered offense. The game came down to the wire, with the Giants holding on for a 21-17 victory.
This upset set the stage for the Giants’ improbable Super Bowl run, where they would go on to defeat the previously undefeated New England Patriots. The Giants’ resilience and ability to perform under pressure were key factors in their success, highlighting the unpredictable nature of the NFL playoffs.
The Giants’ defensive strategy was crucial in this upset. They managed to limit the effectiveness of the Cowboys’ Pro Bowl wide receiver Terrell Owens and tight end Jason Witten, forcing Romo to rely on less reliable targets. The defensive line, featuring Strahan, Osi Umenyiora, and Justin Tuck, consistently pressured Romo, sacking him twice and forcing several hurried throws.
On offense, Manning displayed remarkable composure, completing 12 of 18 passes for 163 yards and two touchdowns. Running backs Brandon Jacobs and Ahmad Bradshaw provided a balanced attack, combining for over 130 rushing yards. This game highlighted the importance of a well-rounded team effort and the ability to execute under pressure, as the Giants’ defense and offense combined to pull off a stunning upset.
8. 1998 NFC Championship: Atlanta Falcons vs. Minnesota Vikings
The 1998 NFC Championship Game between the Atlanta Falcons and the Minnesota Vikings was another classic upset in NFL playoff history. The Vikings, led by quarterback Randall Cunningham and featuring a record-setting offense, were heavy favorites. They had posted a 15-1 regular-season record and were expected to cruise to the Super Bowl.
The Falcons, led by quarterback Chris Chandler and running back Jamal Anderson, were determined to prove the doubters wrong. The game was a high-scoring affair, with both teams exchanging blows. With the game tied at 27-27, Vikings kicker Gary Anderson, who had not missed a field goal all season, missed a crucial attempt late in the fourth quarter.
The game went into overtime, where Falcons kicker Morten Andersen nailed a 38-yard field goal to give Atlanta a 30-27 victory. This stunning upset sent the Falcons to their first Super Bowl and demonstrated the unpredictable nature of the playoffs, where even the most dominant teams can fall.
The Falcons’ defensive strategy was pivotal in this upset. They managed to limit the effectiveness of the Vikings’ star wide receiver Randy Moss, who had been a dominant force throughout the season. Cornerback Ray Buchanan had a standout performance, making key tackles and deflecting passes. On offense, Chandler delivered a clutch performance, completing 27 of 43 passes for 340 yards and three touchdowns.
Anderson, known for his “Dirty Bird” touchdown celebration, provided balance with his powerful running, amassing 67 yards and a touchdown. This game highlighted the importance of a balanced attack and the ability to perform under pressure, as the Falcons’ offense and defense combined to pull off one of the most surprising upsets in playoff history.
9. 2011 AFC Divisional Playoff: New York Jets vs. New England Patriots
The New York Jets’ victory over the New England Patriots in the 2011 AFC Divisional Playoff was a significant upset, given the Patriots’ dominance during the regular season. Led by quarterback Tom Brady, the Patriots were the top seed in the AFC and were expected to make a deep playoff run.
The Jets, led by head coach Rex Ryan and quarterback Mark Sanchez, played a near-perfect game. Their defense, known for its aggressiveness, managed to disrupt Brady and the Patriots’ high-powered offense. Sanchez delivered a solid performance, and the Jets capitalized on their opportunities. The game ended with a 28-21 victory for the Jets, shocking the football world and showcasing the importance of peaking at the right time. This upset highlighted the Jets’ tenacity and strategic brilliance, as they executed their game plan to perfection.
The Jets’ defensive strategy was crucial in this upset. They managed to limit the effectiveness of the Patriots’ star wide receiver Wes Welker and tight end, Rob Gronkowski, forcing Brady to rely on less reliable targets. Cornerbacks Darrelle Revis and Antonio Cromartie had standout performances, shutting down the Patriots’ top receiving options.
On offense, Sanchez displayed remarkable composure, completing 16 of 25 passes for 194 yards and three touchdowns. Running back LaDainian Tomlinson provided balance with his powerful running, amassing 82 yards and a touchdown. This game highlighted the importance of a well-rounded team effort and the ability to execute under pressure, as the Jets’ defense and offense combined to pull off a stunning upset.
10. 1994 AFC Championship: San Diego Chargers vs. Pittsburgh Steelers
The final upset on our list is the San Diego Chargers’ victory over the Pittsburgh Steelers in the 1994 AFC Championship. The Steelers, led by head coach Bill Cowher and quarterback Neil O’Donnell, were heavy favorites to win and advance to the Super Bowl. The Chargers, led by quarterback Stan Humphries and head coach Bobby Ross, were considered underdogs.
The game was a defensive battle, with both teams struggling to score. The Steelers held a 13-3 lead in the third quarter, but the Chargers mounted a comeback. Humphries connected with wide receiver Tony Martin for a 43-yard touchdown, cutting the deficit to 13-10. In the fourth quarter, Humphries threw a 43-yard touchdown pass to tight end Alfred Pupunu, giving the Chargers a 17-13 lead.
The Chargers’ defense held strong, and they secured the victory, earning their first trip to the Super Bowl. This upset demonstrated the Chargers’ resilience and ability to perform under pressure, showcasing the unpredictable nature of the NFL playoffs.
The Chargers’ defensive strategy was crucial in this upset. They managed to limit the effectiveness of the Steelers’ running game, led by running back Barry Foster and forced O’Donnell into making critical mistakes. Linebacker Junior Seau had a standout performance, making key tackles and providing leadership on the field. On offense, Humphries displayed remarkable composure, completing 19 of 29 passes for 290 yards and two touchdowns.
Wide receiver Tony Martin provided a deep threat, making several key receptions to move the chains. This game highlighted the importance of a well-rounded team effort and the ability to execute under pressure, as the Chargers’ defense and offense combined to pull off a stunning upset.
Conclusion
The NFL playoffs have provided countless unforgettable moments, with underdog teams rising to the occasion and defying the odds. These top 10 playoff upsets in history are a testament to the unpredictability and excitement of the sport. From last-minute heroics to defensive masterclasses, these games have left an indelible mark on NFL history and continue to be celebrated by fans and analysts alike.
The common thread in all these upsets is the combination of preparation, execution, and the ability to perform under pressure. Whether it’s a last-minute drive, a crucial defensive stop, or a game-winning field goal, these moments remind us why we love the game of football.
Each of these upsets encapsulates the essence of what makes the NFL playoffs so compelling: the belief that anything is possible. They underscore the importance of resilience, strategic brilliance, and the sheer will to win, regardless of the odds. These games have not only changed the fortunes of franchises but have also carved out legendary statuses for the players and coaches involved. They serve as a source of inspiration, teaching us that no obstacle is insurmountable and that perseverance can lead to greatness.
Moreover, these historic upsets have contributed to the rich tapestry of NFL lore, providing future generations with tales of incredible feats and improbable victories. They illustrate that football is not just a game of physical prowess but also one of mental toughness and tactical ingenuity. As we look back on these monumental moments, we celebrate the underdog spirit that makes the NFL playoffs a stage for some of the most dramatic and unforgettable events in sports history. These upsets remind us that in football, as in life, the true measure of success is not just in the final score but in the heart, determination, and tenacity displayed on the field.
