Ah, the perpetual battle for Spider-Man supremacy. With a slew of movies and a host of actors donning the red and blue spandex, the debate has never been more alive. Is Tobey Maguire the one true Spidey, or does Tom Holland swing higher? Does Andrew Garfield deserve another shot at the role? Luckily, we’ve got something that may put an end to the never-ending fan arguments: Rotten Tomatoes rankings of all the Spider-Man movies. That’s right, the definitive (well, according to some) critic-aggregator site has spoken. Let’s dig into this web of cinematic successes and flops, shall we?
“Here is every Spider-Man film ranked by Rotten Tomatoes score.”
Why the Spotlight is Back on Spider-Man
Before we begin, it’s worth noting that Spider-Man is currently stealing headlines, yet again, for two primary reasons. The video game Marvel’s Spider-Man 2 has just been released on the PS5, and the movie Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse is now available on Netflix.
“October has Spider-Man back in the spotlight thanks to the release of the video game Marvel’s Spider-Man 2 on the PS5 as well as Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse coming to Netflix.”
So, grab your popcorn and let’s get started.
The Not-So-Amazing Spider-Man 2 (51%)
Despite Andrew Garfield’s earnest attempt to bring depth to Peter Parker, The Amazing Spider-Man 2 remains at the bottom of the Rotten Tomatoes barrel. It’s a movie famous, or rather infamous, for its emotional gut-punch of an ending: the death of Gwen Stacy.
“Without a third film, Peter Parker is left devastated over her death, and it is not until Andrew Garfield appears in Spider-Man: No Way Home that his counterpart of Peter Parker, is offered a chance at redemption.”
You can catch this teary-eyed spectacle on Netflix and Disney+.
The Fall from Grace: Spider-Man 3 (63%)
If memes could save a movie, Spider-Man 3 would be a masterpiece. Instead, the film is mostly remembered for Peter Parker’s emo phase and that jazz club scene we’d all like to forget. It’s as if the symbiote affected the film’s quality, too.
“The villains also do not hold up to the exciting danger that follows the dastardly Green Goblin and Doc Ock, leaving for a reasonably dull conclusion.”
You can cringe-watch this installment on Netflix and Disney+.
The Other Garfield Entry: The Amazing Spider-Man (71%)
Coming in at 71%, The Amazing Spider-Man was a decent attempt to revamp the franchise with a new face. Andrew Garfield’s take on Peter Parker is quirky, but perhaps that’s not enough to carry the entire movie.
“Peter’s discovery of his powers and the villains he faces are never quite memorable enough to give the movie as much life as it would need.”
You can catch this one on Netflix and Disney+ as well.
The OG Web-Slinger: Spider-Man (2002) (90%)
Directed by Sam Raimi and starring Tobey Maguire, this film set the template for superhero movies to come. Ah, those were the days when we were introduced to the iconic phrase: “With great power comes great responsibility.”
“His origin story — catalyzed by Uncle Ben’s death — plunges Peter into the emotional turmoil that helps anchor the movie.”
It’s a nostalgia trip worth taking on Netflix and Disney+.
The European Adventure: Spider-Man: Far From Home (90%)
Tom Holland’s second solo outing as Spider-Man provides a refreshing European backdrop and a love story that makes the hearts of MCU fans flutter.
“Far From Home received the silver medal and is the second-highest-grossing Spider-Man movie, earning approximately $1.132 billion at the box office.”
Catch it on Starz for a blend of action and romance.
The Fresh Recruit: Spider-Man: Homecoming (92%)
Tom Holland’s debut in the role was a delightful introduction to a younger, more enthusiastic Peter Parker who’s eager to prove himself. Plus, Michael Keaton as Vulture? A big win for villain characterization.
This one’s available for streaming on Disney+.
The Sophomore Hit: Spider-Man 2 (93%)
Tobey Maguire’s second round as Spider-Man is often hailed as one of the best superhero sequels ever made. With Alfred Molina’s unforgettable Doc Ock and the iconic “Pizza time,” it’s hard to argue.
It’s available on Netflix and Disney+ for your viewing pleasure.
The Crossover Spectacle: Spider-Man: No Way Home (93%)
The highest-grossing Spider-Man movie ever made, No Way Home pulls off the unprecedented feat of uniting three generations of Spider-Men in one film.
“All three Peter Parkers get a sense of closure or redemption from their respective installments, and it was the type of event that fans had dreamed about for years.”
It’s a cinematic miracle that can be enjoyed on Amazon Prime Video.
Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse (96%)
Following in the footsteps of its predecessor, the animated sequel understands the importance of doing Miles’ job as Spider-Man justice. Fortunately, Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse does not disappoint in terms of animation, action, or story. Viewers get to view a variety of Spider-People from other realms, as well as understand how canon events effect each and every masked hero.
The Animated Crown Jewel: Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse (97%)
Considered by many to be the epitome of Spider-Man movies, Into the Spider-Verse is a multi-layered, visually stunning masterpiece that explores the theme of anyone being able to wear the mask.
“Into the Spider-Verse explores not just the story of Miles Morales but also of Peter Parker, Spider-Woman, and others, reflecting the very essence of the Spider-Man mythos.”
Watch this ground-breaking animated movie on Netflix.
Final Thoughts: The Web Is Wide Enough for All
Whether you’re a die-hard Tobey Maguire fan or rooting for Tom Holland, the Rotten Tomatoes rankings show that there’s a Spider-Man movie for everyone. So, what are you waiting for? Get that popcorn ready, and indulge in some web-swinging cinematic greatness.
