When “How I Met Your Mother” (HIMYM) first appeared on screens in 2005, it quickly captured the hearts of audiences with its quirky storytelling and charismatic cast. Despite its success, not everyone was convinced from the start, especially one of its stars, Neil Patrick Harris. Harris, who portrayed the unforgettable Barney Stinson, was initially doubtful about the show’s potential, particularly due to its unconventional title.
“I got an audition for this show called ‘How I Met Your Mother,’ which I thought was a terrible title… And I thought it would just be up to pilot and would never go, because of the title.”
His concerns stemmed from the title’s lack of simplicity and catchiness, which he felt were crucial for a show’s longevity and appeal. Despite these reservations, Harris’s portrayal of Barney became one of the show’s highlights, adding a significant comic edge that contributed greatly to its popularity. His transformation of Barney from the initial concept—envisioned as a “retoud, cigar-smoking, Jack Black” type—to the charming and slick character loved by fans, showcased his ability to elevate the material given to him.
Jason Segel’s Behind-the-Scenes Struggles
While Neil Patrick Harris found ways to thrive within the framework of HIMYM, co-star Jason Segel faced his own set of challenges, particularly during the show’s later seasons. Known for his role as the loveable Marshall Eriksen, Segel’s off-screen experience was less joyful. In a discussion with The Hollywood Reporter’s Comedy Actor Roundtable, Segel opened up about his personal and professional challenges during this time.
“There was a period in my life and career around the last couple of years of How I Met Your Mother where things were firing in both movies and TV, and everyone was telling me how well it was going,” Segel shared. “And I was really unhappy.”
The actor felt creatively confined and yearned to explore more diverse and dramatic roles, a desire that culminated in his portrayal of David Foster Wallace in “The End of the Tour,” marking a significant shift from his comedic roots.
Conclusion: A Show That Defied Expectations
“How I Met Your Mother” not only survived its allegedly ‘terrible’ title but thrived, becoming a beloved staple in TV history. The show’s ability to blend humor with heartfelt storytelling, coupled with the strong performances of its cast, proved that initial doubts could be overcome with creativity and dedication. Both Neil Patrick Harris and Jason Segel, despite their differing experiences and initial skepticism, contributed uniquely to the show’s enduring legacy. As viewers continue to revisit and celebrate the series, the behind-the-scenes insights from Harris and Segel offer a deeper appreciation for the complexities involved in creating television that resonates with audiences across the globe.
